Our Story

A church with and for Healdsburg. Rooted in two traditions since the 1850s.

Where it began

Cyrus Alexander's living room

Yes, that Alexander. The pioneer who gave Alexander Valley its name came to California in the 1830s and managed the vast Sotoyome rancho that became the land around Healdsburg.

In 1852, before Healdsburg was even a town, he gave up the best room in his house so a Methodist circuit rider could lead worship. A few years later he became a Presbyterian elder, and when the Methodists' church fell into debt, he bought it and gave it to the Presbyterians. Methodists and Presbyterians, sharing and giving to one another: that's been our story ever since.

The two-story Alexander ranch house with a long porch and picket fence, about 1870
The Alexander ranch house, about 1870

1852 to today

Our timeline

  1. 1857

    A place in the new town

    When Harmon Heald laid out the town that would bear his name, he set aside lots for a Methodist church and a Presbyterian church.

  2. 1858

    The Presbyterians organize

    Rev. James Woods organized the First Presbyterian Church of Healdsburg on October 10, with Cyrus Alexander as a founding elder. At first they worshipped in the Methodists' church.

  3. 1860s

    A gift between neighbors

    When the Methodists' church on the Plaza fell into debt, Alexander bought it and gave it to the Presbyterians, who worshipped there for nearly forty years.

  4. 1870s

    A white wooden church with a square bell tower on a dirt street
    Methodist Episcopal Church, 1873. Sonoma County Library

    Two Methodist churches

    Healdsburg had both a Methodist Episcopal church at Fitch and Haydon Streets and a Southern Methodist church on East Street, a split dating to before the Civil War.

  5. 1901

    A church on Fitch Street

    The Presbyterians opened a new church at 217 Fitch Street on Easter 1901. It became the Federated Church's home for most of the next century.

  6. 1924

    A white wooden church with a steeple behind a picket fence
    Southern Methodist Church, c. 1885. Sonoma County Library

    Methodists reunite

    Healdsburg's two Methodist churches, northern and southern, merged into one congregation.

  7. 1936

    Rebuilt after a fire

    A fire badly damaged the Fitch Street church in December 1935. The congregation rebuilt and rededicated it the next fall.

  8. 1970s–80s

    Bill Hayes

    Rev. Bill Hayes, a Navy veteran and former electronics engineer, served as pastor for more than two decades, the longest pastorate in our history.

  9. 1990

    A new home on University Avenue

    The congregation sold its Fitch Street property to St. John's, which uses it for its school today, and opened a new building at 1100 University Avenue in November 1990.

  10. 1998

    Thirteen years of shared leadership

    Revs. Dave and Becca Jordan-Irwin served as co-pastors for thirteen years. Our building became home to English tutoring and to recovery meetings that continue today.

  11. 2013

    Portraits of Pastors Dean and Andrea Kladder
    Dean and Andrea Kladder

    Dean and Andrea Kladder

    Revs. Dean and Andrea Kladder arrived as co-pastors, leading a new season of ministry with kids, youth, and families.

  12. 2017

    Neighbors in the fires

    When wildfires swept through Sonoma County, HCC helped feed evacuees and offered listening training for people carrying the weight of loss.

  13. 2024

    The Tiny Food Pantry

    We dedicated the Tiny Food Pantry outside our doors, the first little free pantry in Healdsburg, open to anyone who needs it.

  14. 2025

    The sanctuary emptied out during the renovation, with a bare concrete floor and work tables
    The sanctuary during the renovation, 2025

    Down to the bare floor

    We took the sanctuary down to the bare floor and rebuilt it, with new flooring, new lighting, and a new stage.

Some things haven't changed

For 170 years we've been centered on Jesus, connected to congregations near and far through our two denominations, and here with and for Healdsburg.